The Psychology of Urgency: How to Ethically Make Readers Take Action Now
Ever seen a ‘Last Chance!’ sale that mysteriously appears again next week? That’s urgency done badly—and it’s why so many customers are sceptical.
We have all been encouraged to buy by the “last chance”, it's often the push we need to actually get around to whipping out that credit card and making the payment.
It’s a welcome push when done well, as we all love to buy something we want, and we don’t want to miss out.
Urgency can be a great driver if used well, but when misused, it can quickly erode trust, if the “last chance” is just one of many last chances.
The Science Behind Urgency & Scarcity
Ever found yourself rushing to grab an item because there were “only 2 left in stock”? Or booking a hotel room faster than planned because “5 other people are looking at this right now”? That’s urgency and scarcity in action.
We’re wired to act when we feel like time is running out or when something we want might slip away. It’s called Loss Aversion—the idea that we’d rather avoid losing something than gain something new. Add in Fear of Missing Out (FOMO), and suddenly, a decision we were putting off feels urgent.
Brands know this well. Think of Black Friday sales, limited-edition product drops, or airline deals that expire at midnight. Done right, these tactics create excitement and drive action.
But here’s the key: it only works when it’s real. If customers start noticing the same “low stock” or “ending soon” messages over and over, they stop believing them, and when trust is gone, so is the sale.
How NOT to Use Urgency: Common Ethical Pitfalls
Urgency is powerful—but only when people believe it. The moment your audience realizes your “limited-time offer” isn’t actually limited, you’ve lost them.
Here’s where urgency goes wrong:
False Scarcity
Telling people “Only 3 spots left!” when there’s really no limit isn’t just misleading—it’s a fast track to losing trust. If someone sees the same offer available days later, they’ll question everything you say.
Never-Ending Deadlines
If every email says “Final Chance!” but the same deal pops up next week, people stop taking your deadlines seriously. When urgency becomes predictable, it stops working.
Overuse of Urgency
If everything is urgent, nothing is. When every single offer, email, and sales page screams “Act now!”, people start tuning it out. Real urgency stands out because it’s not used all the time.
Bait-and-Switch Tactics
Saying an offer is “exclusive” when it’s not is a surefire way to make people feel tricked. If someone buys thinking they’re getting a one-time deal, only to see the same “exclusive” offer a month later, they won’t fall for it again.
What Happens If You Get This Wrong?
People stop trusting you.
Your audience starts ignoring your promotions.
Your word no longer means anything.
Urgency loses its power, along with your conversions.
The good news? You don’t need fake urgency to sell. The next section covers how to use urgency ethically, so it actually works.
How to Use Urgency the Right Way (Without Being Pushy)
Urgency should feel like a helpful nudge, not a high-pressure sales tactic. When done right, it encourages action without making people feel manipulated. Here’s how to use urgency ethically—so it actually works.
✅ Use Genuine Scarcity
If spots are limited, explain why. Maybe you can only take on 10 clients because you offer personalised feedback. Maybe a product is a true limited edition. The key is transparency.
And if you set a deadline, stick to it. No surprise extensions or “by popular demand” reopenings. If people realize you don’t mean what you say, your next deadline won’t mean anything either.
✅ Tie Urgency to Value, Not Just Pressure
Instead of just saying, “Act now before it’s too late!”, connect urgency to the value they’ll receive.
➡ “Sign up now to get personalized feedback before the doors close.”
➡ “Join today and get access to the live Q&A session.”
When urgency is tied to benefits, it feels like a real opportunity, not a pushy sales trick.
✅ Create Time-Sensitive Bonuses Instead of False Deadlines
Rather than pretending an offer is disappearing, make bonuses the time-sensitive element.
➡ “Sign up in the next 48 hours and get a free strategy session.”
➡ “Join today and get an exclusive behind-the-scenes training.”
This way, the main offer remains available, but there’s still a compelling reason to act fast.
✅ Be Transparent About Future Opportunities
People appreciate honesty. If your offer will be available again, say so.
➡ “This course will reopen in six months, but this is your chance to get in at the early-bird rate.”
This builds trust while still giving people a reason to act now instead of waiting.
✅ Test & Refine What Works for Your Audience
Not all urgency tactics work the same for every business. Pay attention to how your audience responds.
Are they engaging more with your emails?
Are conversions improving?
Or are they ignoring your promotions because they see urgency too often?
Use urgency strategically, and it will drive real action—without making people feel pressured.
Conclusion: Urgency That Builds Trust, Not Breaks It
Urgency isn’t about pressuring people into buying—it’s about giving them a genuine reason to act now. When used ethically, it can boost sales and strengthen trust. But the moment urgency feels like a trick, people start questioning everything you say.
Short-term sales gimmicks might work once or twice, but long-term relationships are what actually grow a business. When customers trust that you mean what you say, they’re far more likely to take action, now and in the future.
So, think about the last time you felt genuine urgency in a purchase decision. What made it feel real? Now, apply that same thinking to your own business. When urgency is done right, you don’t just get sales—you build trust that keeps people coming back.
If you want your readers to take action, but you’re too busy focusing on coaching, let's talk.
I help personal brands and coaches craft high-converting emails that drive revenue and authority. Fill in this quick form, and we can get things started.
Hey there, Rebecca here.
My mission is to write copy that feels unmistakably you—capturing your voice, sharing your stories, and engaging your audience in a way that drives real impact.
